GabrielKnight
19-01-2010, 20:39
Generally, is the same cc engine better with 8v or 16v?
A search never seems conclusive, with those saying that 16v must be bigger and better by definition, but as many other people prefer 8v, citing the following reasons (correct or otherwise):
1. 8v are easier to repair.
2. 16v tend to tear timing belts causing valve train damage.
3. 16v are not as common as 8v so parts are more expensive.
4. 16v are not as common as 8v so mechanics have less experience on rarer models
5. 16v are hard on fuel.
As far as performance is concerned 8v is supposed to have better torque at slow speeds and 16v at higher speeds. I guess I'd prefer higher torque at higher speeds because 1/4 mile races are rarer on the UK roads where I spend 99% of my time.
A search never seems conclusive, with those saying that 16v must be bigger and better by definition, but as many other people prefer 8v, citing the following reasons (correct or otherwise):
1. 8v are easier to repair.
2. 16v tend to tear timing belts causing valve train damage.
3. 16v are not as common as 8v so parts are more expensive.
4. 16v are not as common as 8v so mechanics have less experience on rarer models
5. 16v are hard on fuel.
As far as performance is concerned 8v is supposed to have better torque at slow speeds and 16v at higher speeds. I guess I'd prefer higher torque at higher speeds because 1/4 mile races are rarer on the UK roads where I spend 99% of my time.